William F. Laurance
William F. Laurance is a biologist in the research department at The Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute in Panama which studies tropical nature and its importance for human well-being. Its objective is also to promote conservation by generating interest in the beauty and richness of tropical ecosystems amongst the general public. His latest book to date is entitled “Emerging Threats to Tropical Forests” (C. A. Peres Co-Ed. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, USA). He is also president of The Association for Tropical Biology and Conservation (ATBC) which is accepted as the largest scientific organisation dedicated to the study and protection of tropical ecosystems.
Forest destruction: The road to ruin
12/09/2008 2:27 pm
Such environmental perils are increasingly common across much of the world as native forests are fragmented, waterways polluted, and oceans over-harvested. The onslaught is especially alarming in the tropics, where an area of forest the size of 40 football fields is destroyed every minute. Thousands - perhaps millions - of species are at risk.
Yet remarkably, many developing nations have good laws to regulate development and protect their natural ecosystems. Indonesia, Brazil, Bolivia and the Democratic Republic of the Congo, for example, all have strong forestry codes and environmental laws. So why aren't they working?
A key problem is that environmental impact assessments (EIAs), required by law for most development projects, are often utterly inadequate. Nowhere is this clearer than in Brazilian Amazonia, which is yielding to the biggest expansion in paved highways in its history. By greatly increasing access to the heart of the Amazon, these highways are opening a Pandora's box of threats such as illegal logging, hunting, mining and land colonisation. But the EIAs for these new highways only evaluated the direct effects on the narrow strip of land being cleared for each road. None of the alarming indirect impacts that commonly follow highway construction were covered.
A similarly narrow evaluation is under way for the planned expansion of the Panama Canal, which will allow supertankers to travel the waterway. As less than 700 hectares of rainforest will be destroyed, everyone expects the project will get the green light. Yet this $5.2 billion scheme will have a profound impact on a nation as small as Panama. Increased land speculation, overheated development and growing demand for construction timber will put pressure on forests across the country. Even cursory consideration of the project's indirect effects reveals these issues.
In addition, many EIAs are laughably superficial. For example, a biological survey for a planned housing complex in Panama's suburban forests identified only 12 common bird species. A 2-hour census of the same area by experienced birdwatchers tallied 121, including several rare and threatened species. The project was approved despite scientists' warnings to the authorities of flaws in the study.
Why are EIAs often so poor? Firstly, they are usually paid for by the project backer, who pushes to ensure approval with minimum costs. In such a system, environmental firms that get projects accepted with few mitigation measures are in high demand, while those with a rigorous reputation are avoided.
Secondly, government agencies that evaluate EIAs often fail to apply their own environmental rules. The process is also vulnerable to corruption, since government employees are often poorly paid while project backers have deep pockets and a large financial stake to protect. Even EIAs with glaring faults are sometimes approved.
Finally, it is rare for a project to be halted on environmental grounds because the burden of proof falls on those who oppose it, not those who favour it. A planned highway might sever a critical forest corridor, or open up a pristine valley to exploitation, but unless it can be shown that it would irreparably harm an endangered species or rare ecosystem, the road may be approved regardless. Fighting development projects takes considerable time, money and expertise, and this stacks the deck heavily against citizens and public-interest groups who often oppose risky developments.
What can be done to improve the situation? Increasing public awareness should help focus attention on the EIA process and its many weaknesses - including a dire need to evaluate both the direct and indirect impacts of major projects. Equally important is greater involvement by society and by environmental groups. Government agencies that approve or halt projects are often responsive to external pressure, and they rely on lobbying by conservationists to help balance development forces. If you want to help the global environment, supporting an active environmental group in a developing nation may be a key strategy.
Of course, serious flaws in EIAs are not confined to developing countries. The drafter of the US Environmental Protection Act, Lynton Caldwell, has often bemoaned the failure of EIAs to balance the needs of nature against human activities. But in developing nations, conservation interests are often less established, and pressures for exploitation are stronger and more immediate. Better environmental decision-making is crucial if we are to limit these growing threats to the natural world.
William F. Laurance
New Scientist, 06 June 2007
© Reed Business Information
Did you enjoy this piece of news ?
Subscribe to our daily newsletter Join us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter-
Certified wood or nothing ! -
Green picnics -
Improved cookstoves in Cambodia schools -
Holistic Conservation Program for Forests in Madagascar -
Agroforestery in Niger -
Reforestation in Colombia -
Reforestation in Chile -
Construction and diffusion of improved cookstoves in Cambodia -
"Green charcoal" in Senegal -
Solar cookers in the Andean Countries







Jon R. Luoma, a contributing editor at Audubon, has written about environmental and science topics for The New York Times, and for such magazines as National Geographic and Discover. In previous...

The Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) is a specialized agency of the United Nations. It was founded on 16 October 1945 in Quebec City, Quebec, Canada. In 1951 its...
Don Cheadle, an award-winning American actor, rose to prominence in the late 1990s and the early 2000s In addition, he played the lead in the movie Traitor, which was directed by Jeffrey Nachmanoff...
@font-face { font-family: "Times New Roman"; }@font-face { font-family: "Arial"; }p.MsoNormal, li.MsoNormal, div.MsoNormal { margin: 0cm 0cm 0.0001pt; font-size: 12pt; font-family: "Times New Roman";...
Li Bingbing, one of China’s most popular actresses, is well known for her achievements both on and off the screen. Her latest movie is Detective Dee and the Mystery of the Phantom Flame. Throughout...
Sachin Tendulkar - UNEP Goodwill Ambassador - is the first player to score fifty centuries in all international cricket. He is widely acknowledged as one of the greatest batsmen in the history of the...
Fred Pearce is journalist specialized in the environment and development. He was born in the United Kingdom and studied geography in the University of Cambridge. His latest book is When the Rivers...
Yann Arthus-Bertrand is a famous photographer. He has always had a passion for the animal world and the natural environment. In 1991 he founded Altitude, the world’s first aerial photography agency...
Yevgenia Albats is Professor of Political Science at The Higher School of Economics and Editor of The New Times Magazine.
Jim Robbins is a veteran journalist based in Helena, Montana. He has written for the New York Times, Conde Nast Traveler, and numerous other publications. His fifth book, The Forgotten Forest, about...
William F. Laurance is a biologist in the research department at The Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute in Panama which studies tropical nature and its importance for human well-being. Its...
Professor Virgílio Viana is one of Brazil’s leading experts on forestry, environment and sustainable development. He served as Secretary of State for Environment and Sustainable Development and is...
Survival is an international organization supporting tribal peoples worldwide, founded in 1969 after an article by Norman Lewis in the UK's Sunday Times which highlighted the massacres, land thefts...
Olivier BOUYER est Ingénieur du Génie Rural, des Eaux et Forêts. Il a participé à la conférence de Poznan (en 2008) avec la délégation française comme chargé de mission “effet de serre et forêt””...
Vandana Shiva (India): Physicist, epistemologist, ecologist, and Indian feminist with a PhD in the philosophy of science. She founded “Navdanya,” an association which works to protect biodiversity...
Thierry Jaccaud is chief editor of the magazine L’Ecologiste (french version of The Ecologist) since its creation in 2000. He graduated with honors from the Higher Institute for Environmental...
Nathalie de NOBLET-DUCOUDRE is a researcher at the LSCE (environment and climate sciences laboratory). She studies climate evolution, the role of man, and biogeochemical cycles which affect climate...
Lester Russel Brown, famous author of more than 50 books on the environment and founder of the Worldwatch Institute in the United States, urges us to become more aware of the many services forests...